Monday, May 16, 2011

Kes Liwat II: Sah, DSAI Perlu Bela Diri


Hakim sedang membaca teks penghakimannya. Masih belum ada apa-apa keputusan yang diberikan.

Hakim masih bercerita tentang sejarah kes.

Kata Hakim Zabidin "What was needed to be proved is a prima facie case, credible evidence to ingredient of offence." Kita tunggu keputusannya, adakah penghakimannya adalah refleksi kata-katanya?

Kata Hakim Zabidin Twitter TMI):

 [Terkini]  Judge Zabidin says prosecution proven all facts to define charge. Prima facie case made out against accused. 

Judge Zabidin calls Anwar to enter defence. 

 Justice Zabidin: No reason for this court not to accept evidence in this case. 

Judge Zabidin says accused was the last occupant in cell before towel, mineral water bottle, toothbrush taken for DNA sampling. 

Justice Zabidin: The other crucial evidence is DNA evidence. 
 Justice Zabidin: I find nothing inconsistent with doctors' findings. 
Justice Zabidin: All three doctors testified positively, conclude there was penile penetration. 

Judge Zabidin says chemist's evidence shows swabs taken from PW1. "These swabs confirmed presence of semen." 

Justice Zabidin: I find accused & complainant at crime scene, opportunity for crime to take place.


Judge Zabidin says hard to accept defence's submission that Saiful not on 5th floor. 


 Justice Zabidin: Defence contened PW1 not truthful witness. I found PW1 credible witness, his evidence is reliable. 
  
Justice Zabidin: I find him to be a good, true witness, evidence is reliable, if accepted can be used.

Justice Zabidin: I find PW1's evidence remains intact.

Judge finds it not tenable to use PW1's failure to escape as reason not to believe his testimony.

Justice Zabidin: PW1 followed instructions of accused after incident, did not immediately lodge police report.

Justice Zabidin: With greatest respect, I find this irrelevant.

Justice Zabidin: It was not surprising defence had tried to paint a picture of PW1 as someone who has zero credibility.

Justice Zabidin: If court finds PW1 not credible witness, then accused is acquitted.


Kemas Kini:
Butiran beritanya di sini: Kes liwat: Anwar diarah bela diri

No comments:

Post a Comment